I love nurse Jackie. It's probably not good to advertise this, but in some aspects she's a very realistic nurse. She's probably got a little bigger dose of crazy than the average nurse for entertainment's sake, but if you divide her oddities up and distribute them among a handful of nurses, you probably have it about right.(The answer by the way is Unemployed.)
I always thought nursing could benefit from a really good realistic show. Shows like House, and ER really haven't been helping us much. In ER the nurses are occasionally visible, but always on their way to med school it seems. In House they're pretty much nonexistent.
Don't even get me started on HawthoRNe...that show is just an embarrassment to us all.
Actually, let me get started on HawthoRNe for a second, because I really feel like the non-nursing public needs to know how we feel about this one. For those of you not familiar, HawthoRNe is a relatively new show on TNT staring Jada Pinkett Smith as some sort of head nurse. Why the head nurse for the whole hospital is involved in patient care and hanging around the ER all day is beyond me, but that's the least of this show's problems.
HawthoRNe has a few of the usual (and somewhat forgivable) hospital show problems. For one, the boundaries of the different areas of the hospital are fluid. Nurses, doctors, and whoever, are easily moved from one part of the hospital to another depending on the plot needs. This often results in a nurse working in the ER one day and on a regular hospital floor caring for the same patient the next day as the plot requires. This wouldn't happen. Number two is that they really don't stick to the realistic abilities of your average community hospital. Obviously the hospital is somewhat small in HawthoRNe, but that doesn't stop them from participating in the sorts of treatments you'd see in your large, research facilities.
But I'll let those slide. There are a few unforgivable sins committed by HawthoRNe however, that the nursing community will not, and the public should not, allow to occur in nursing-based TV shows (or other media, for that matter.) This list is not necessarily in order of importance. Also be aware that my critique is limited to season 1 (if God-forbid, there are more seasons down the road, I want to make that point clear.) This is obviously because I couldn't stand watching any more of it. I'm not entirely sure how I watched as many episodes as I did.
Unforgivable Sin #1: The male nurse is a joke. There's only one on HawthoRNe, and he's embarrassing to male nurses everywhere. The only thing he has going for him is that he's straight, and therefore breaks the often-held stereotype of the gay male nurse (although I'd take Nurse Jackie's ultra-gay male nurse Mo-Mo any day over this moron.) He's an incompetent, weak, Dr-wannabe. He spends his days drooling over the slutty nurse on his unit, despite her flaws (which we'll get to next.) The writers lose no chance to make him look ridiculous. On the few times that they do allow him to have a bright idea, it's squashed by his complete lack of a pair of testicles.
I'm going to be truthful here. I've known many male nurses. They tend to accumulate in the type of nursing that I work in, which is highly skilled and intense, and so I've had the pleasure of working with many of them. They are none of the things that HawthoRNe makes them out to be. They are masculine, they are straight, gay, all different colors. They are fresh out of college, and they are the 50 year old with 3 teenage kids. They are highly intelligent and very emotionally in tune with the world around them. Contrary to public opinion they are all types of men, none of the types being stupid. Also, and listen very carefully to this one, they got into nursing to be NURSES, not because they couldn't become a doctor, the education is not interchangeable. You do not get to be a nurse automatically because you went to med school and failed. Congrats HawthoRNe, they weren't having enough problems being a male nurse, it's a good thing you made the label a little more embarrassing.
Unforgivable Sin #2: The Slut.
This actually may be the most important unforgivable sin of HawthoRNe, I couldn't decide (which is why I decided not to order them by importance.) This ridiculous specimen of nursing is who male nurse has chosen to be in love with, despite her flaws. It's a big flaw too...(cover your kids eyes for this one...) she gives certain sexual favors to patients. Mainly patients who served in some branch of the armed forces. Apparently she does this often enough that in one episode, a young man comes into the ER and requests her specifically. This prompts a warning from idiotic male nurse that perhaps this isn't a good idea, and she would get in trouble if people found out. Yeah, that's right. Not a completely normal reaction like ICK ICK ICK ICK ICK OMG ICK!!! He simply says "you shouldn't do that anymore...but ya you're still hot, so I'd still do you." OK, so that's not exactly what he says, but that is the gist of it.
This has a couple of problems. First of all, as a young cute nurse, I get hit on fairly often. This ranges from the completely innocent grandpa telling me that I'm cute to skeezy guy asking me for favors of a sexual nature. Nursing in general has not been served by the naughty nurse costumes of the last 100 years or so, and almost every nurse gets hit on. To be honest, age and attractiveness don't matter much. This drives us all crazy. If you say something uncomfortable to us when we first meet you, we have to continue to interact with you for another 12 hours....not cool. This episode perpetuates this discomfort x10, into infinity.
The second problem is that this has NEVER happened. Sorry guys, didn't mean to crush your hopes, but no actual FEMALE health care worker with college education has ever done this. EVER. I could tolerate unfavorable views of nurses if they were realistic, but this is not. It's icky. I'm sorry to all you male patients out there once again, but when you're in that hospital bed, you're not really seen as a fully functioning human being with us. Your penis isn't really noted as a penis, just another appendage of you. We kind of think of you as children that need our care. You are not viewed in a sexual capacity at all. That would be, well, icky.
To summarize. Nursing has enough working against us, what with the costumes mentioned above and with half the porn in existence. You could make the chicken and egg argument with this one, and we could go round and round trying to decide if that's a symptom or a cause, but at the end of the day it doesn't need to be perpetuated by a show that isn't supposed to be sexual in nature.
Unforgivable Sin #3
The show is just stupid. OK, maybe we could have gotten this out of the way early, but it's one of the show's smaller problems, so it gets to be #3. The writing is terrible, the plot unbelievable, and the acting causes more eye rolling than praise. This really doesn't have much to do with the nursing aspects of the show, but its unforgivable just the same.